Allegation of Research Misconduct


ALLEGATION OF RESEARCH MISCONDUCT

Allegation of Research Misconduct is a policy and procedure for receiving, assessing, investigating, and addressing allegations of violations of research integrity and scholarly publication ethics, including plagiarism, data fabrication and falsification, duplicate publication, and other forms of academic misconduct. This policy aims to ensure that all allegations are handled objectively, fairly, transparently, and on the basis of verifiable evidence. The Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to safeguarding research integrity, editorial transparency, and the reliability of the scholarly record through procedures consistent with internationally recognized publication ethics standards. This policy applies to manuscripts under review as well as articles that have already been published. Every allegation must be examined proportionately, with relevant parties given an opportunity to provide clarification before an editorial decision is made. Accordingly, an allegation does not automatically constitute proven misconduct before an appropriate evidence-based assessment has been completed.

1
Definition and Scope of Research Misconduct

Research and publication misconduct encompasses actions that compromise honesty, reliability, attribution, or transparency in conducting research or disseminating its findings. Such misconduct may include, but is not limited to, the following:

  • Plagiarism: using ideas, text, data, images, or other work belonging to others without adequate attribution, including plagiarism of one's own previously published work.
  • Data fabrication: inventing data, research findings, sources, or evidence that were never actually obtained or produced.
  • Data falsification: manipulating research materials, procedures, data, images, or results so that the research record no longer accurately represents the actual research process or findings.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication: republishing substantially similar content without appropriate disclosure, attribution, or justification, or submitting the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals in violation of applicable publication policies.
  • Authorship misconduct: including individuals who do not meet authorship criteria, excluding eligible contributors, or engaging in guest, gift, or ghost authorship.
  • Citation manipulation: engaging in inappropriate or irrelevant citation practices to artificially increase citation counts, including unjustified coercive citation.
  • Image or visual material manipulation: misleading alteration of images or visual materials, undisclosed duplication of images, or presentation of visual evidence that does not accurately represent the original data.
  • Research ethics violations: conducting research involving human participants, animals, communities, or sensitive data without required consent, authorization, safeguards, or ethical procedures.
  • Violations involving Indigenous peoples and local communities: disregarding required consent, community rights, confidentiality, ownership of knowledge, or cultural norms in relevant research.
  • Failure to disclose: failing to disclose relevant conflicts of interest, funding sources, permissions for materials, or other information that may materially affect the assessment of research.
  • Editorial process misconduct: manipulating peer review, using false reviewer identities, falsifying reviewer recommendations, or misusing confidential information obtained during editorial processes.

Unintentional errors, academic disagreements, or technical inconsistencies do not, in themselves, constitute evidence of misconduct. Each case is assessed in relation to its nature, evidence, context, impact, and seriousness.

2
Sources and Submission of Allegations

Allegations of research misconduct may be submitted by any individual or organization with reasonable grounds and relevant information, including:

  • Reviewers or editors who identify potential problems during manuscript evaluation.
  • Authors, readers, other researchers, or members of the academic community.
  • Affiliated institutions, funding agencies, or relevant professional bodies.
  • Other journals or publishers possessing evidence of duplicate publication or misconduct involving multiple journals.

Reports should include the identification or reference of the manuscript or article, a specific description of the alleged problem, and supporting evidence such as comparative sources, documents, data, or relevant links. Anonymous reports may be considered when the information and evidence provided are sufficient for preliminary assessment. Reports lacking verifiable information may require additional clarification.

Reports should be submitted confidentially to the Editor-in-Chief through the official contact channels provided on the JIED journal website.

3
Receipt of Allegations and Preliminary Assessment

Editors or designated editorial representatives conduct a preliminary assessment to determine whether the report contains a specific, relevant allegation supported by sufficient evidence for further examination. This assessment may include text similarity checks, publication comparisons, image or data examination, and review of relevant documents and correspondence.

  • Reports and evidence received are recorded internally.
  • The complainant may be asked to provide additional information or evidence when necessary.
  • Reports lacking sufficient grounds may be closed with documented reasons.
  • Where adequate grounds exist, the editor proceeds with further examination and contacts relevant parties as appropriate.

Editorial examination aims to assess the implications of the alleged problem for the manuscript or scholarly record. The journal does not replace institutional authority in conducting formal investigations into researchers' conduct or imposing employment-related sanctions.

4
Examination and Investigation Procedures

When sufficient grounds exist to proceed, JIED undertakes an examination proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the allegation. The procedure may include the following steps:

  1. Collecting, securing, and documenting relevant evidence.
  2. Notifying the author or relevant party of the substance of the allegation and providing a reasonable opportunity to submit clarification and supporting evidence.
  3. Examining responses, documents, data, comparative sources, and other relevant information objectively.
  4. Seeking assessment from independent editors, subject specialists, or ethics advisers when necessary.
  5. Contacting affiliated institutions, funding agencies, or relevant authorities when necessary, particularly where the allegation requires formal investigation beyond the journal's authority.
  6. Documenting the assessment outcome and determining proportionate editorial action based on the available evidence.

Authors accused of misconduct must be given a fair opportunity to respond to the allegation. Failure to respond does not automatically establish misconduct; however, editors may proceed with an assessment based on the available evidence and, where appropriate, seek assistance from relevant institutions.

5
Confidentiality, Impartiality, and Conflicts of Interest

Allegations of misconduct are handled with due confidentiality and protection of the integrity of the examination process. Information is shared only with parties who need it to address the case, subject to applicable legal requirements and obligations.

  • Editors, reviewers, and advisers involved in a case must disclose relevant conflicts of interest.
  • Individuals with a relevant conflict of interest must not participate in decision-making; the case is reassigned to an appropriate independent editor or party.
  • The identity of complainants requesting confidentiality will be protected to the extent possible, taking into account investigative needs and applicable legal requirements.
  • Information concerning allegations that have not been substantiated must not be disclosed inappropriately.
6
Editorial Decisions and Actions

After evaluating the evidence, clarifications, and other relevant information, the editor determines the outcome in writing. Actions are based on the seriousness of the misconduct, its implications for research reliability and the scholarly record, and the journal's applicable policies.

Possible Editorial Actions
Manuscript Correction: Requesting revision or clarification before publication when the issue can be resolved without undermining the principal reliability of the research.
Manuscript Rejection: Rejecting a manuscript when misconduct is substantiated or the manuscript fails to meet the journal's ethical and scholarly standards.
Correction or Corrigendum: Publishing a correction when an error affects a specific part of an article but the overall findings and conclusions remain reliable.
Expression of Concern: Publishing a statement of concern when a serious issue is under investigation and the available evidence or investigative outcome does not yet permit a final decision.
Retraction: Retracting a published article when sufficient evidence establishes that its findings or conclusions are unreliable, serious plagiarism or redundant publication has occurred, or other grounds for retraction are met.
Notification to Institutions: Providing relevant evidence and information to affiliated institutions, funding agencies, or appropriate authorities when necessary for formal investigation.
Editorial Restrictions: In serious cases supported by documented evidence, the journal may consider restrictions on future submissions in accordance with applicable written policies, ensuring a fair and proportionate process.

Retraction aims to correct the scholarly record, rather than simply punish authors. An article is not retracted automatically merely because an allegation has been submitted. Permanent blacklisting or public disclosure of unsubstantiated allegations is not an automatic action under this policy.

7
Handling of Published Articles

When an allegation concerns an article that has already been published, the editor assesses whether the issue affects the reliability of data, findings, conclusions, attribution, or publication integrity. Any action taken must be proportionate to the problem identified.

  • A correction is issued when the problem is limited and the article remains reliable overall.
  • An Expression of Concern may be issued when serious concerns remain unresolved.
  • Retraction is considered when evidence indicates that the article is unreliable or meets other applicable retraction criteria.
  • Correction or retraction notices must be clear, accessible, and linked to the relevant article whenever possible.

When the outcome of an examination is inconclusive, the editor may request additional information from relevant institutions. If necessary to protect readers and the scholarly record, the journal may publish an Expression of Concern while awaiting further investigation.

8
Cooperation with Institutions and Relevant Organizations

JIED may coordinate with authors' affiliated institutions, funding agencies, other journals, or relevant authorities when a case requires formal investigation or involves multiple parties. Institutions are generally responsible for investigating researchers' conduct and determining institutional actions, whereas the journal is responsible for determining editorial measures necessary to safeguard the reliability of the scholarly record. The journal will consider institutional findings alongside other relevant evidence.

9
Documentation, Communication, and Case Closure

The journal maintains relevant internal records of reports, evidence, correspondence, responses from involved parties, decisions, and actions taken, while observing confidentiality and applicable requirements. Relevant parties will be informed of the outcome to the extent possible. If sufficient evidence does not substantiate the allegation, the case may be closed and relevant parties notified that no further action will be taken on the basis of the available evidence. Case information will not be disclosed inappropriately.

10
Publication Ethics Guidelines and References

This policy is based on the principles of scholarly publication integrity and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). In handling cases, the journal may apply appropriate COPE guidance according to the type of allegation, including procedures for addressing suspected misconduct and guidance on article retraction.

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE):
https://publicationethics.org/
COPE Retraction Guidelines:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4
COPE Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.12
COPE Guidance on Cooperation between Research Institutions and Journals:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2018.1.3

The Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to protecting research integrity, ensuring fair and impartial investigations, and safeguarding the reliability of the scholarly record.