Retraction and Correction


RETRACTION AND CORRECTION POLICY

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to maintaining the accuracy, transparency, and integrity of the scholarly record through the implementation of its Retraction and Correction Policy. This policy establishes procedures for addressing errors, inaccuracies, research integrity concerns, and suspected ethical violations identified after an article has been published. The principal objective is to ensure that published articles retain a clear, traceable, and academically accountable publication status. In implementing this policy, JIED distinguishes between corrections, including errata and corrigenda, article retractions, and the publication of an expression of concern. The appropriate action is determined by the nature and seriousness of the problem, its implications for the reliability of research data, findings, and conclusions, and the evidence available. Each case is handled objectively, proportionately, and transparently, with reasonable opportunities for authors and relevant parties to provide clarification. Where necessary, the journal may seek independent expert advice or coordinate with relevant institutions. This policy is informed by the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and internationally recognized practices in scholarly publication integrity. Through this policy, JIED seeks to ensure that every correction or retraction is responsible, documented, and appropriately linked to the relevant article, thereby preserving reader confidence and the reliability of the scholarly record.

1
Purpose and Principles of the Policy

This policy aims to ensure that published articles retain a clear and trustworthy publication status. Corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions are implemented to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record and provide readers with adequate information.

  • Maintain the accuracy and reliability of published scholarly information.
  • Ensure that all changes to published articles are transparent and traceable.
  • Provide authors and relevant parties with reasonable opportunities to provide clarification.
  • Prevent readers from unknowingly relying on or citing information that is known to be inaccurate or unreliable.
  • Preserve the scholarly publication record and the history of article changes, subject to applicable legal requirements and platform capabilities.

Important principle: Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly literature, not merely to punish authors. Unintentional errors may warrant correction or retraction when their effects on article reliability meet the relevant criteria.

2
Types of Changes to Published Articles

The Editorial Board determines the appropriate action based on the nature of the error, its impact on the article, and the reliability of its findings or conclusions. The following actions may be considered:

A. Correction Notice

An official notice issued to correct errors in a published article when the correction is sufficient to maintain the clarity and reliability of the publication record without requiring the article to be retracted.

B. Erratum (Publisher Correction)

An erratum addresses errors introduced during editorial or publishing processes, such as layout errors, formatting problems, typographical mistakes introduced during production, or other technical inaccuracies. Its terminology and application may follow the conventions of the journal, publisher, and relevant indexing systems.

C. Corrigendum (Author Correction)

A corrigendum addresses errors originating from the authors, such as inaccuracies in data, tables, figures, supplementary information, funding statements, or authorship information. A correction may be published when the problem can be transparently rectified without requiring article retraction. If the error substantially undermines the reliability of the findings, the editor will consider a more appropriate action. The original article generally retains its existing DOI. Changes resulting from a corrigendum are documented in a correction notice linked to the original article and made accessible to readers and other relevant parties.

D. Expression of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when serious concerns exist regarding the integrity or reliability of an article, but the available evidence is insufficient to reach a final decision. This may occur when an investigation is ongoing, the relevant institution has not completed its examination, or essential information cannot yet be verified. The statement will be reconsidered when relevant information becomes available.

E. Retraction

Retraction is a formal action notifying readers that a published article is no longer reliable in its entirety or that other serious grounds justify its withdrawal from the reliable scholarly literature. A retraction is based on an examination of evidence and editorial assessment, rather than solely on allegations or disputes between parties.

3
Criteria for Issuing Corrections

A correction may be issued when an error or omission is identified in a published article, but the problem does not require the article to be retracted in its entirety. Examples include:

  • Typographical, formatting, or bibliographic errors requiring correction.
  • Verifiable errors in author names, affiliations, acknowledgements, or funding information.
  • Limited inaccuracies in tables, figures, numerical values, labels, or text that can be clearly corrected.
  • Errors or omissions that do not fundamentally alter the main interpretation, validity, or conclusions of the article.
  • Other inaccuracies that, following editorial assessment, can be corrected without misleading readers about the reliability of the research.

Minor errors that do not affect comprehension, attribution, or the scholarly record may be addressed through technical corrections where the publishing system permits and where such changes do not conceal substantive revisions. Substantive changes to published articles must not be made silently.

4
Criteria for Retraction

JIED may consider retracting an article when the available evidence demonstrates one or more of the following circumstances:

  • Unreliable data or findings: Serious errors, incorrect calculations, or methodological problems materially undermine the validity of the findings and conclusions.
  • Fabrication or falsification: Research data, results, images, or materials have been invented, manipulated, or misleadingly presented.
  • Serious plagiarism or redundant publication: Substantial material has been published without appropriate attribution, or an article has been improperly republished.
  • Research ethics violations: Research has involved serious breaches of consent, participant protection, authorization, or relevant ethical standards.
  • Rights and material-use violations: Data, materials, or works have been used without relevant authorization, making the publication untenable in its published form.
  • Publication process manipulation: Evidence indicates manipulation of peer review, fictitious authorship, or other misconduct that seriously compromises publication integrity.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest: Serious undisclosed conflicts materially affect the interpretation or recommendations presented in the article.
  • Other serious grounds: Circumstances substantially undermine the reliability or integrity of the article and justify retraction following editorial evaluation.

Editorial consideration: Retraction is not automatic merely because an error, allegation, or academic disagreement exists. The Editor must assess whether a correction is sufficient to resolve the problem or whether the article as a whole is no longer reliable.

5
Procedure for Requesting and Issuing Corrections

A correction request may be submitted by authors, editors, readers, or other parties with relevant evidence. The handling procedure includes:

  1. The reporting party provides the article title, author names, DOI or article link, description of the error, its location in the article, supporting evidence, and proposed correction.
  2. The editor conducts an initial assessment to determine the nature and origin of the error and its implications for the article's content and conclusions.
  3. The editor may request clarification from the corresponding author, other authors, independent reviewers, or relevant experts where necessary.
  4. For corrections involving authorship, changes to author order, or the addition or removal of authors, the editor may require a written explanation and consent from all affected parties. If an unresolved dispute arises, the journal may seek clarification from the relevant institution.
  5. The editor determines whether the error requires an erratum, corrigendum, another form of correction notice, an expression of concern, or a retraction.
  6. If a correction is approved, the journal prepares a notice explaining the error, the correction, and its implications for the article's interpretation.
  7. The correction notice is published separately where appropriate and linked to the original article. Metadata and DOI information are updated or linked in accordance with the technical capabilities of the publishing system and applicable indexing policies.

The decision to issue a correction rests with the Editorial Board. Author approval may be sought to ensure factual accuracy, but an author's disagreement does not automatically prevent editorial action when sufficient evidence requires correction to preserve the scholarly record.

6
Article Retraction Procedure

Article retraction is conducted through a documented and proportionate editorial process. The procedure includes:

  1. Receiving or identifying a report, evidence, or information that raises serious concerns about the reliability or integrity of an article.
  2. Conducting an initial assessment and preserving relevant evidence, including data, documents, comparative publications, and available correspondence.
  3. Informing the relevant authors about the substance of the concerns and providing a reasonable opportunity to submit clarification or counter-evidence.
  4. Seeking independent expert input or contacting affiliated institutions and relevant organizations where necessary, particularly when formal investigation exceeds the journal's authority.
  5. Evaluating the evidence and responses objectively and determining whether the issue can be resolved through correction or requires article retraction.
  6. Publishing a clear and timely retraction notice once sufficient grounds for a decision have been established.
  7. Updating the article page, notice links, and relevant metadata to the extent supported by the publishing system and indexing services.

Editorial responsibility: The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the final editorial decision unless a conflict of interest or other circumstance requires the case to be handled by an independent editor. Where the evidence remains inconclusive but serious concerns persist, the journal may issue an expression of concern pending further examination.

7
Requirements for Correction and Retraction Notices
A. Correction Notice

A correction notice must provide sufficient information for readers to identify the changes and understand their implications. Where relevant, the notice includes:

  • The title of the corrected article, author names, and publication information.
  • The DOI or link to the original article.
  • A clear description of the error and its correction.
  • An explanation of the correction's implications for findings, interpretation, or conclusions, where relevant.
  • The publication date of the notice and a traceable correction document identifier.
B. Retraction Notice

A retraction notice must be transparent, objective, and readily accessible to readers. It should contain at least:

  • The title of the retracted article, author names, and relevant bibliographic information.
  • The DOI or permanent link to the original article and retraction notice.
  • An explicit statement that the article has been retracted or is designated as Retracted.
  • Factual and sufficiently specific reasons explaining the underlying concerns.
  • Identification of the party issuing or determining the retraction, such as the Editorial Board, authors, or relevant parties, where appropriate.
  • The publication date of the notice and a clear connection to the original article record.

Notices must not contain insulting, speculative, or accusatory language beyond what can be substantiated. Reported information must be consistent with the available evidence and examination outcomes.

8
Preservation of the Original Article, DOI, and Metadata

To maintain transparency and traceability in scholarly publishing, JIED applies the following provisions to the extent supported by its publishing platform and indexing services:

  • Published articles generally remain available as part of the scholarly record, including after retraction, with their retracted status clearly displayed.
  • The HTML or PDF version of a retracted article is clearly marked, such as with a RETRACTED label, or accompanied by a prominent notice indicating its status.
  • The retraction notice must be linked to the original article, and the original article must provide a link to the retraction notice.
  • Correction or retraction notices are published freely and without unnecessary access restrictions.
  • The DOI of the original article is not removed solely because the article has been retracted. DOI and metadata information for correction or retraction notices are managed according to the publishing system and DOI registration requirements.
  • Article status information and relevant links are updated on the journal website and communicated to relevant indexing or metadata registration services where necessary and feasible.

Complete removal of an article from the journal website may only be considered under exceptional circumstances, such as legal obligations or serious risks to privacy and safety. Where removal cannot be avoided, the journal will preserve adequate bibliographic information and a notice to the extent permitted by law and the technical capabilities of the platform.

9
Impartiality, Confidentiality, and Conflicts of Interest

Every correction request or concern that may result in retraction is handled fairly and independently. The journal applies the following principles:

  • Individuals with a conflict of interest must not control the assessment or decision concerning the case.
  • Authors are given a reasonable opportunity to respond before a final decision, except where urgent and justifiable reasons require temporary protective action.
  • The identity of reporting parties and confidential information are protected as far as possible, subject to the needs of the examination and applicable legal obligations.
  • Editorial decisions are based on evidence, not institutional pressure, commercial interests, author reputation, or other non-scholarly considerations.
  • Where necessary, the journal may coordinate with affiliated institutions, funding bodies, independent editors, or relevant authorities.
10
Submission of Reports or Requests

Authors, readers, reviewers, institutions, or other parties with relevant evidence may submit reports concerning errors or suspected problems in published articles. Reports should preferably include:

  • The article title, author names, DOI, or article link.
  • A specific explanation of the reported error or concern.
  • Supporting evidence and comparative sources, where available.
  • A proposed action or correction, if identifiable.
  • The reporting party's contact information, if further clarification is required.

Reports should be submitted confidentially to the Editor-in-Chief through the official editorial contact channel listed on the JIED contact page. Anonymous reports may be considered when the evidence provided is sufficient for assessment. The journal does not guarantee that every report will result in a correction or retraction; actions are determined based on the examination findings and available evidence.

11
International Guidelines and References

This policy is developed with reference to relevant international publication ethics guidelines. These guidelines inform the journal's decisions concerning appropriate actions for published articles.

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE):
https://publicationethics.org/
COPE Retraction Guidelines:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4
COPE Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.12
COPE Guidance on Cooperation between Research Institutions and Journals:
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2018.1.3
Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to preserving the integrity of the scholarly publication record through transparent, fair, proportionate, and accountable correction and retraction procedures.