Reviewer Guidelines

 

Reviewer Guidelines

The Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to maintaining the quality, integrity, and scholarly relevance of published research. Reviewers play an essential role in ensuring that submitted manuscripts meet appropriate academic standards through constructive, objective, and independent evaluation.

Review Model: JIED applies a double-blind peer review system. Reviewers are not informed of the authors' identities, and authors are not informed of the reviewers' identities. Reviewers are expected to maintain confidentiality and avoid any attempt to identify the authors.

1. Guidelines for Reviewers
1. Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts objectively, based on their scholarly quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and contribution to the field.
2. Reviewers should provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based comments that help authors improve their manuscripts. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate.
3. Reviewers should identify relevant published works that have not been cited by the authors. Any observation concerning plagiarism, redundant publication, or other research misconduct should be communicated confidentially to the editor.
4. Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts received for evaluation. Manuscripts and their contents must not be shared, discussed, or used for personal or professional advantage without authorization from the editor.
5. Reviewers should disclose any potential conflict of interest and decline the review when impartiality may be compromised. They should also inform the editor if the manuscript falls outside their expertise or if they cannot complete the review within the required timeframe.
2. Reviewer Evaluation Form

Reviewers are requested to complete the reviewer evaluation form and provide detailed comments on the manuscript's academic quality, originality, methodological soundness, clarity, and relevance to the journal's scope. The evaluation should include specific recommendations for improvement and a publication recommendation.

Reviewer Registration: Reviewers who have not registered with JIED may register through the journal's online system: Register as a Reviewer.

3. Evaluation Questions

Reviewers should consider the following questions when evaluating a manuscript:

No. Evaluation Criteria
1 Does the manuscript fit the focus and scope of JIED?
2 Does the manuscript demonstrate originality and a clear contribution to knowledge?
3 Is the research problem clearly formulated and adequately justified?
4 Are the research objectives clearly stated and aligned with the research problem?
5 Is the literature review sufficiently comprehensive, relevant, and up to date?
6 Does the manuscript establish an adequate theoretical or conceptual framework?
7 Are the research methods appropriate and adequately described?
8 Are the data, analysis, and findings presented clearly and systematically?
9 Are the findings interpreted appropriately and supported by the evidence?
10 Does the discussion engage critically with relevant scholarly literature?
11 Are the conclusions consistent with the research findings and objectives?
12 Does the manuscript adequately explain its theoretical, methodological, or practical implications?
13 Is the manuscript logically organized, coherent, and written in clear academic language?
14 Are the citations and references relevant, accurate, and consistent with the journal's requirements?
15 What revisions are necessary to improve the manuscript, and what is your final recommendation?
4. Review Type

Anonymous Reviewer / Anonymous Author

JIED employs a double-blind review process in which the identities of both authors and reviewers remain confidential throughout the evaluation. Reviewers must not disclose their identity in their reports or communicate directly with authors regarding manuscripts under review. All review correspondence should be conducted through the journal's editorial system.

Related Editorial Policies

Reviewers are expected to understand and comply with JIED's editorial policies governing manuscript evaluation. The Peer Review Process explains the procedures and stages of manuscript assessment, while the Publication Ethics policy establishes ethical expectations concerning confidentiality, impartiality, conflicts of interest, and research integrity. Reviewers should also consult the Focus and Scope to assess the relevance of submitted manuscripts and the Allegation of Research Misconduct policy when concerns about research integrity arise during review. Further guidance on editorial decisions and publication corrections is available in the Retraction and Correction policy.

Reviewer Commitment: By accepting a review assignment, reviewers agree to evaluate manuscripts fairly, maintain confidentiality, disclose potential conflicts of interest, and provide timely, constructive, and academically responsible feedback in accordance with JIED's editorial policies.

```