Author Guidelines

AUTHOR GUIDELINES

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED)

These author guidelines provide essential information for preparing and submitting manuscripts to the Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED). Authors are expected to follow the journal's editorial standards, manuscript structure, formatting requirements, citation practices, and publication ethics before submitting their manuscripts.

IMPORTANT REQUIREMENTS
  • Manuscript length: 5,000–8,000 words, excluding references.
  • Maximum manuscript length: 15 pages.
  • Font: Palatino Linotype, 11 pt.
  • Line spacing: 1.15.
  • Paper size: A4.
  • Reference style: APA 7th Edition.
  • Manuscripts must be original and not under consideration by another journal.

1. General Requirements for Manuscript Submission

JIED welcomes original scholarly manuscripts that fall within its focus and scope, particularly research and academic discussions concerning Islamic education, Islamic thought, Islamic intellectual traditions, and contemporary Islamic educational discourse.

Submitted manuscripts must demonstrate academic relevance, originality, methodological rigor, and a clear contribution to the development of knowledge. Authors should ensure that their manuscripts are written in an academically appropriate style, supported by relevant scholarly literature, and prepared in accordance with the journal's guidelines.

  • Manuscripts must constitute original scholarly work.
  • Manuscripts must not have been published previously or be under consideration for publication elsewhere.
  • All listed authors must have made substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript.
  • The manuscript must comply with the journal's publication ethics and research integrity standards.
  • Authors must submit manuscripts through the JIED Online Journal System (OJS).
Submission Policy
Submission of a manuscript to JIED implies that the work is original, has not been published previously, and is not simultaneously submitted to another publication.

2. General Manuscript Formatting

All manuscripts must be prepared using Microsoft Word and follow the formatting specifications below.

Formatting Component Requirement
File Format Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx)
Paper Size A4
Font Palatino Linotype
Font Size 11 pt for the main text
Line Spacing 1.15
Margins Top and left: 2.5 cm; bottom and right: 2 cm
Length 5,000–8,000 words, excluding references; maximum 15 pages
Citation Style APA 7th Edition

Authors should use consistent formatting throughout the manuscript. Headings, subheadings, paragraphs, tables, figures, and references should be organized clearly and consistently.

3. Manuscript Structure

Research manuscripts submitted to JIED should generally follow the structure outlined below. Authors may adapt the internal organization of sections according to the research design and scholarly conventions of their discipline, while maintaining the essential components of an academic manuscript.

3.1. Title

The title should clearly and concisely represent the central topic, research problem, or principal contribution of the manuscript.

  • The title should contain a maximum of 14 words.
  • The title should be written in Palatino Linotype, 18 pt.
  • The title should be clear, informative, and academically appropriate.
  • Unnecessary abbreviations and overly general expressions should be avoided.

3.2. Author Names and Affiliations

Authors should provide their full names without academic titles or professional designations. Each author's institutional affiliation should be clearly indicated.

The author information should include:

  • Full name of each author.
  • Institutional affiliation and country.
  • Author email addresses.
  • The corresponding author's email address, clearly identified.

Author names and affiliations should be presented consistently and accurately. The corresponding author is responsible for communication with the editorial office throughout the submission and publication process.

3.3. Abstract

The manuscript must include an abstract written in English. The abstract should be presented in one paragraph and should not exceed 250 words.

The abstract should briefly and clearly describe:

  • Background: the research context and principal problem.
  • Purpose: the research objectives and, where relevant, hypotheses.
  • Methods: the research design, data, participants or sample, and analytical procedures.
  • Results: the principal empirical, theoretical, or analytical findings.
  • Implications: the relevance of the findings to scholarly understanding, educational practice, or policy.
  • Conclusion: the principal interpretation and implications of the research.

The abstract should be informative, self-contained, and consistent with the contents of the manuscript. Citations, unnecessary abbreviations, and unsupported claims should be avoided.

Abstract Requirement
English abstract: one paragraph, maximum 250 words. The abstract must accurately represent the purpose, methods, principal findings, and implications of the manuscript.

3.4. Keywords

Authors should provide three keywords that represent the principal concepts, subject areas, or themes addressed in the manuscript.

  • Keywords should be placed immediately after the abstract.
  • Keywords should be separated by commas.
  • Keywords should be specific, relevant, and useful for indexing and discoverability.

3.5. Abstrak (Bahasa Indonesia)

Manuscripts should include an Indonesian abstract (Abstrak) that presents a concise description of the research background, objectives, methods, principal findings, implications, and conclusions.

The Indonesian abstract should correspond substantively to the English abstract and should be written clearly and accurately. It should be presented in one paragraph and should not exceed 250 words.

3.6. Kata Kunci

Authors should provide three Indonesian keywords (Kata Kunci) that correspond to the principal concepts and themes of the manuscript. Keywords should be separated by commas and placed immediately after the Indonesian abstract.

3.7. Introduction

The Introduction should establish the scholarly context and rationale for the study. It should be written coherently and demonstrate why the research problem deserves academic investigation.

The Introduction should address the following elements:

  • Research problem: explain the practical or theoretical problem and its significance.
  • Research context: establish the broader academic context of the issue.
  • State of the art: discuss recent and relevant studies and developments in the field.
  • Research gap: identify limitations, unresolved questions, or areas insufficiently addressed by previous studies.
  • Research questions and objectives: clearly formulate the questions and objectives derived from the identified gap.
  • Novelty and contribution: explain the distinctive contribution of the study to existing knowledge.

The Introduction should not merely provide a general description of the topic. It should develop a logical argument that connects the research problem, previous scholarship, research gap, and research objectives.

Introduction: Essential Components
Research problem → Recent scholarly studies → Research gap → Research questions and objectives → Novelty and contribution.

3.8. Methods

The Methods section should explain how the research was conducted and provide sufficient information for readers to understand, assess, and, where applicable, replicate the research process.

Depending on the research design, this section should include:

  • Research approach and design.
  • Research setting, participants, subjects, or data sources.
  • Sampling procedures and selection criteria.
  • Materials, instruments, or research tools.
  • Data collection procedures.
  • Data analysis techniques and analytical procedures.
  • Relevant methodological references and justifications.
  • Ethical approval and research ethics procedures, where applicable.

New methods, procedures, or analytical techniques should be described in sufficient detail. Established methods may be explained briefly with appropriate scholarly references.

Authors should disclose relevant ethical approvals and approval codes for research involving human participants, animals, or other activities requiring ethical review. Data availability and restrictions concerning research materials or information should also be stated where applicable.

The Methods section should be concise, clear, and adequate for evaluating the methodological rigor of the study. As a general guideline, it should not exceed 10% of the main text for qualitative research or 15% for quantitative research.

3.9. Results

The Results section should present the principal findings of the research in a systematic, coherent, and evidence-based manner. Findings should be organized according to research questions, objectives, analytical categories, or relevant themes.

  • Present findings clearly and logically.
  • Use appropriate subheadings to organize the results.
  • Refer to tables and figures appropriately in the text.
  • Present empirical evidence, analytical results, or theoretical findings relevant to the research questions.
  • For qualitative research, relevant interview excerpts, observation records, documentary evidence, or textual interpretations may be presented to substantiate findings.
  • Ensure that reported findings are consistent with the research data and analytical procedures.

Interpretation and comparison with previous studies should primarily be developed in the Discussion section, unless the research design requires the integration of Results and Discussion.

3.10. Discussion

The Discussion should interpret the findings in relation to the research questions, theoretical framework, and relevant previous studies. Authors should move beyond describing the results and develop a critical and analytical explanation of their significance.

The Discussion should:

  • Explain the meaning and significance of the principal findings.
  • Compare and critically engage with relevant previous studies.
  • Identify similarities, differences, and possible explanations for the findings.
  • Explain the theoretical, conceptual, methodological, or practical implications of the research.
  • Demonstrate how the findings address the research gap.
  • Clarify the contribution and limitations of the study.
  • Identify relevant directions for future research where appropriate.

Claims and interpretations should be supported by evidence and scholarly literature. Authors should avoid unsupported generalizations and conclusions that extend beyond the available data.

3.11. Conclusions

The Conclusions section should provide a concise synthesis of the principal findings and their significance. It should demonstrate consistency between the research objectives stated in the Introduction and the findings discussed in the manuscript.

The conclusion should:

  • Address the research questions and objectives.
  • Summarize the principal findings and interpretations.
  • Highlight the main contribution of the research.
  • Explain relevant implications or prospects for further development.

Conclusions should not introduce new empirical findings, extensive literature discussions, or claims that have not been established in the preceding sections.

3.12. Acknowledgment

The Acknowledgment section may be used to recognize individuals, institutions, or organizations that contributed meaningfully to the research but do not qualify for authorship.

Authors may acknowledge:

  • Research funding agencies or financial support.
  • Institutions providing research facilities or resources.
  • Individuals providing substantive research assistance or scholarly feedback.
  • Relevant seminars or conferences where the research was presented.

Funding sources should be identified accurately and transparently.

4. In-Text Citations

All sources used in the manuscript must be cited appropriately using the APA 7th Edition author-date citation system. Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy and completeness of citations.

4.1. Author-Date Citation

In-text citations should identify the author's surname and publication year.

  • Parenthetical citation: (Ayu, 2024).
  • Narrative citation: Ayu (2024) explains that ...
  • Two authors: (Ayu & Budi, 2024).
  • Three or more authors: (Ayu et al., 2024).
  • Direct quotation: include the author's surname, year, and page number where available.

4.2. Citation Accuracy

Authors must ensure that every cited source is accurately represented and that all citations correspond to entries in the reference list. Direct quotations must be reproduced faithfully and clearly distinguished from the author's own writing.

Authors are encouraged to use reference management software, such as Mendeley or Zotero, to maintain consistency and accuracy in citations and references.

5. References

The reference list must contain all sources cited in the manuscript and must be prepared in accordance with the APA 7th Edition style.

  • References should be arranged alphabetically by the surname of the first author.
  • All cited sources must appear in the reference list.
  • Sources listed in the reference list must be cited in the manuscript.
  • Authors should provide complete bibliographic information.
  • DOIs should be included whenever available and presented in URL format.
  • Authors should verify the accuracy of author names, titles, publication years, journal names, volume, issue, pages, and DOI information.
  • Reference management software is strongly recommended.
Reference Style
JIED applies APA 7th Edition. Authors should not use numbered references or arrange references according to their order of appearance in the text.

5.1. Journal Article

Author, A. A., & Author, B. B. (Year). Title of the article. Title of Journal, volume(issue), page–page. https://doi.org/xxxxx

5.2. Book

Author, A. A. (Year). Title of the book. Publisher.

5.3. Chapter in an Edited Book

Author, A. A. (Year). Title of the chapter. In B. B. Editor (Ed.), Title of the book (pp. xx–xx). Publisher.

5.4. Online Sources

Author, A. A. (Year, Month Day). Title of the webpage. Website Name. URL

Authors should consult the official APA guidelines for other reference types and ensure that all references are formatted consistently.

6. Tables, Figures, and Mathematical Components

Tables, figures, diagrams, photographs, charts, and mathematical components should be prepared clearly and presented consistently throughout the manuscript.

6.1. Tables

  • All tables must be numbered consecutively (Table 1, Table 2, and so on).
  • Each table must be cited in the manuscript text.
  • Table titles should be placed above the table.
  • Tables should be positioned centrally and close to their first citation.
  • Table contents should be clear, concise, and readable.
  • Authors should avoid unnecessary tables and ensure that each table contributes meaningfully to the manuscript.

6.2. Figures and Illustrations

  • All figures must be numbered consecutively (Figure 1, Figure 2, and so on).
  • Each figure must be cited in the manuscript text.
  • Figure captions should be placed below the figure.
  • Figures should be placed near their first citation.
  • Images and diagrams must be sufficiently clear and readable.
  • For multiple-panel figures, each panel should be identified and explained in the caption.

6.3. Mathematical Components

Equations should be centered and numbered consecutively. Equation numbers should be placed in parentheses and aligned with the right margin. Authors are encouraged to use Microsoft Equation Editor or MathType.

Mathematical symbols, statistical notation, and formulas should be presented consistently and accurately. Statistical reporting should include relevant information required to interpret the analytical results.

6.4. Numerical Presentation

For manuscripts written in English, thousands should be separated by commas (e.g., 1,200,300). Decimal points should be indicated using periods (e.g., 12.34). For values below one, the leading zero may be omitted where appropriate for statistical reporting (e.g., .12).

7. Research Ethics and Publication Integrity

Authors must ensure that their research and manuscripts comply with established principles of research ethics and publication integrity. Research involving human participants, animals, sensitive information, or other ethically regulated activities must follow applicable ethical requirements.

  • Ethical approval must be obtained where required by the relevant institution or research regulations.
  • The name of the approving authority and ethical approval code should be reported where applicable.
  • Authors must obtain appropriate consent from research participants where required.
  • Confidentiality, privacy, and protection of research participants must be maintained.
  • Research data must be represented accurately and transparently.
  • Fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, and inappropriate authorship are unacceptable.
  • Conflicts of interest and funding sources must be disclosed transparently.

Authors should also comply with JIED's policies on publication ethics, plagiarism screening, authorship, and the use of generative artificial intelligence.

Research Integrity
Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, ethical compliance, and integrity of their submitted manuscripts. Ethical approval and informed consent must be reported whenever applicable.

Relevant policies:

8. Peer Review and Editorial Process

All manuscripts submitted to JIED are subject to an editorial assessment and peer-review process. Manuscripts are evaluated according to their relevance to the journal's scope, originality, scholarly quality, methodological rigor, clarity, and contribution to the field.

Authors should ensure that their manuscripts are prepared for anonymous peer review where required. Identifying information that may reveal the authors' identities should be removed from the review manuscript and relevant document properties.

Editorial decisions may include acceptance, acceptance with revisions, revision and resubmission, or rejection. Authors are expected to respond to reviewers' comments constructively and provide a clear explanation of revisions made.

Further information:

9. Submission Preparation Checklist

Before submitting a manuscript, authors should ensure that all the following requirements have been fulfilled.

Submission Checklist
  • ☑ The manuscript is original and is not under consideration by another journal.
  • ☑ The manuscript is prepared in Microsoft Word format.
  • ☑ The manuscript follows the required formatting specifications and article structure.
  • ☑ All citations and references follow APA 7th Edition.
  • ☑ Tables, figures, and supplementary materials are properly included and cited.
  • ☑ Ethical approval, consent, funding, and conflict-of-interest information are provided where applicable.
  • ☑ The manuscript has been anonymized for peer review where required.
  • ☑ All authors have approved the submitted manuscript.
  • ☑ The manuscript complies with JIED publication ethics and relevant editorial policies.

10. Online Submission

All manuscripts must be submitted electronically through the JIED Online Journal System (OJS). Authors are required to register or log in to the journal's submission platform before submitting their manuscripts.

Submission steps:

  1. Register or log in to the JIED OJS platform.
  2. Start a new submission and complete the required submission information.
  3. Upload the manuscript file and other required documents.
  4. Enter the metadata, including title, abstract, keywords, and author information.
  5. Confirm that the manuscript complies with the journal's submission requirements.
  6. Complete and confirm the submission process.
Submit Your Manuscript to JIED

JIED Login    Register

11. Revision and Response to Reviewers

Authors receiving a revision decision are expected to revise their manuscripts in accordance with the editor's and reviewers' comments.

  • Address each reviewer comment carefully and systematically.
  • Provide a response document explaining how each comment has been addressed.
  • Identify the revisions made in the manuscript clearly.
  • Provide a scholarly justification when a reviewer suggestion is not adopted.
  • Submit the revised manuscript within the deadline specified by the editorial office.

Revised manuscripts may undergo further editorial assessment or additional peer review before a final decision is made.

12. Proofreading and Final Publication

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts are linguistically clear, grammatically accurate, and professionally presented before publication.

During the production process, authors may be requested to review proofs and verify the accuracy of the final article. Corrections should be limited to errors affecting accuracy, clarity, or presentation and should not introduce substantial changes to the accepted manuscript without editorial approval.

Authors should respond to proof corrections within the timeframe specified by the editorial office.

13. Copyright and Licensing

Authors retain copyright of their published works while granting JIED the rights necessary for publication and dissemination under the journal's licensing terms.

Articles published in JIED are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license. Users may share and adapt published works subject to the conditions of the license, including appropriate attribution and sharing adaptations under the same license.

Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce copyrighted materials, including figures, photographs, tables, or substantial extracts, when permission is required.

Copyright Notice and Licensing

14. Article Template and Submission Information

Authors are strongly encouraged to use the official JIED article template when preparing their manuscripts. The template provides the standard formatting and structural requirements for submission.

Authors are advised to review all relevant journal policies and submission requirements before submitting their manuscripts.

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED)
https://e-journal.upr.ac.id/index.php/jied