Peer Review Process

``


PEER REVIEW PROCESS

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) implements a rigorous double-blind peer-review process to ensure the academic quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of manuscripts considered for publication. All submissions must comply with the journal's Focus and Scope and Author Guidelines. The review process is conducted objectively, professionally, and confidentially, ensuring that the identities of authors and reviewers remain anonymous throughout the evaluation.

Manuscript Review Process
1
Initial Editorial Screening and Scope Assessment

The Editor-in-Chief conducts an initial screening to assess whether the manuscript aligns with the Focus and Scope of JIED, meets the basic submission requirements, and demonstrates sufficient scholarly relevance and quality to proceed to further evaluation. Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope or fail to meet fundamental editorial requirements may be rejected at this stage.

2
Originality Screening and Technical Assessment

The editorial board examines manuscript originality using similarity detection tools, such as Turnitin or equivalent software. The screening also covers manuscript formatting, academic language, citation and reference completeness, and compliance with the journal's Article Template. Manuscripts may be returned to authors for technical corrections before entering the scholarly review stage. Further information is available in the Screening for Plagiarism policy.

3
Double-Blind Peer Review

Manuscripts that satisfy the initial editorial requirements are assigned to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. JIED applies a double-blind peer-review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the evaluation process.

Reviewers assess manuscript originality, theoretical positioning, methodological rigor, analytical depth, quality of evidence, scholarly argumentation, research contribution, and clarity of presentation. They provide objective assessments and constructive recommendations to improve the academic quality of the manuscript in accordance with the Reviewer Guidelines.

Review Timeline

Reviewers are expected to complete their evaluations within approximately 14–21 calendar days after accepting a review assignment. The overall manuscript review process generally takes approximately 2–8 weeks, depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and editorial considerations. Reviewers who require additional time should inform the editor before the review deadline. Extensions may be granted at the editor's discretion.

4
Editorial Decision

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor makes the editorial decision based on reviewers' assessments, manuscript quality, compliance with journal policies, and its scholarly contribution. Reviewer recommendations constitute an important basis for editorial consideration; however, the final decision remains the responsibility of the editor.

Possible Editorial Decisions
●
Accept

The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revisions.

●
Minor Revision

The manuscript requires minor corrections or improvements before acceptance.

●
Major Revision

The manuscript requires substantial revisions before it can be reconsidered for publication.

●
Reject

The manuscript does not meet the journal's scholarly, methodological, or editorial requirements for publication.

5
Revision and Re-review

Authors are required to respond to reviewers' comments and revise their manuscripts within the timeframe specified in the editorial decision. A revised manuscript should be accompanied by a detailed response explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed. The editor may send the revised manuscript to the original reviewers or other qualified reviewers for further evaluation, particularly when substantial revisions are required. The final decision is made after the editor assesses the adequacy of the revisions.

6
Final Editing and Publication

Accepted manuscripts proceed to final editorial processing, language editing, formatting, and proofreading before online publication. Authors are responsible for checking the accuracy of the final manuscript and addressing editorial corrections as required before publication.

Open Access Policy

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) supports the dissemination of scholarly knowledge through open access to published articles. All journal content is freely available online to readers without subscription or access fees, in accordance with the journal's Open Access Policy.

JIED is committed to maintaining an objective, fair, transparent, timely, and ethically responsible peer-review process to safeguard the quality and integrity of scholarly publication.


```