Plagiarism Screening

Plagiarism Screening Policy

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to maintaining originality, academic integrity, and the reliability of scholarly publications. All submitted manuscripts undergo similarity screening to identify potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, inappropriate reuse of authors' own previously published work without adequate attribution, and other forms of publication misconduct. Screening is conducted before or during the editorial and peer-review process and may be repeated when concerns arise after publication. Editorial assessment considers similarity reports, identified sources, the context of textual overlap, citation accuracy, and the severity of the suspected misconduct.

MAXIMUM MANUSCRIPT SIMILARITY

MAXIMUM 20%

The overall similarity index should not exceed 20% as a preliminary screening guideline.

Similarity from a single source should preferably not exceed 5%. Higher similarity from an individual source requires contextual editorial examination.

Manuscripts exceeding these thresholds may be returned for revision or rejected, depending on the evaluation results. A similarity score below 20% does not automatically establish that a manuscript is free from plagiarism.

Important: A similarity index is not automatic evidence of plagiarism. The editorial team examines the context, sources, attribution, and substance of the identified text. Properly cited quotations and references may be excluded from similarity calculations when the screening tool permits such exclusions, but they must still be presented accurately and appropriately.

1. Scope of Screening

Originality screening covers, but is not limited to, the following forms of misconduct:

  • Textual plagiarism: using words, sentences, paragraphs, or sections from another person's work without adequate attribution.
  • Idea plagiarism: using another person's ideas, arguments, theories, or intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgment.
  • Data and visual plagiarism: using data, tables, figures, graphs, research instruments, or other research materials belonging to others without proper citation or permission.
  • Mosaic plagiarism: combining or modifying wording from multiple sources without appropriate attribution, including paraphrasing that remains excessively close to the original text.
  • Inappropriate reuse of one's own work: reusing previously published text, data, or materials without adequate disclosure, citation, or permission.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication: submitting or republishing an entire article or substantial portions of previously published content, data, or findings without adequate disclosure.
  • Simultaneous submission: submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time.
  • Similarity manipulation: attempting to conceal copied text through character substitution, manipulative paraphrasing, or other techniques intended to circumvent screening.

2. Similarity Detection Tools

The editorial team uses text similarity detection tools to identify textual overlap between submitted manuscripts and other available sources. Tools that may be used include:

  • Turnitin — to compare manuscript text against sources available in its database.
  • iThenticate — to screen scholarly manuscripts against available academic publications and sources.
  • Plagiarism Checker X — as an additional tool for textual similarity screening.

The selection of screening tools depends on service availability and screening requirements. Tool-generated reports serve as supporting evidence and do not constitute the final determination of whether plagiarism has occurred.

3. Similarity Index Requirements

Component Requirement
Overall similarity Maximum 20% as a preliminary screening guideline.
Similarity from a single source Preferably not exceeding 5%. Higher similarity from an individual source requires contextual editorial examination.
Quotations and references May be excluded from calculations when the screening tool permits and exclusions are applied consistently. Quotations and references must remain accurate and properly cited.
Further examination May be conducted whenever plagiarism concerns are identified, even when the similarity index is below 20%.

Manuscripts exceeding the similarity threshold may be returned for revision or rejected following editorial evaluation. Meeting the threshold does not automatically guarantee acceptance, while exceeding it does not automatically establish plagiarism.

4. Categories of Findings and Editorial Actions

Screening results are evaluated according to the degree of similarity, the type of material involved, the adequacy of citation, and indications of intentional misconduct. The following categories guide editorial action and do not establish misconduct solely on the basis of percentage scores.

Category Indicators Possible Editorial Actions
Minor Findings Limited textual similarity, paraphrasing errors, or inadequate citations without evidence of serious appropriation of substantive content. Requesting corrections to citations, paraphrasing, or rewriting of the relevant sections.
Substantial Findings Significant similarity across multiple sections, textual reuse without adequate attribution, or duplication requiring clarification. Returning the manuscript for revision, requesting explanations, conducting further examination, or rejecting the submission based on the evaluation.
Serious Misconduct Substantial appropriation of another person's text, ideas, or data without attribution; intentional duplicate publication; or strong evidence of manipulation. Manuscript rejection, formal investigation, notification to relevant institutions when necessary, or post-publication action under journal policies.

Similarity Score: Editorial Attention

A similarity index above 20% triggers further examination. An index above 40% is treated as a high-risk finding requiring comprehensive review. Final decisions are based on evidence, context, and the severity of potential misconduct rather than numerical scores alone.

5. Self-Plagiarism and Duplicate Publication

Authors are not permitted to submit the same article or substantial portions of previously published work without appropriate disclosure and attribution. Reuse of text or materials from an author's own publications must be transparent, properly cited, and consistent with copyright and the requirements of the previous publisher. Reuse of methodological descriptions or other materials does not automatically constitute misconduct in every circumstance. The editorial team will consider the amount and location of reused material, citations to previous work, the originality of the findings, possible data duplication, and copyright implications.

Articles found to constitute duplicate publication or inappropriate reuse of an author's own work may be rejected. If such issues are identified after publication, the editorial team will assess the need for a correction, expression of concern, or retraction according to the severity of the misconduct.

Prohibition of Simultaneous Submission

The same manuscript must not be submitted simultaneously to JIED and another journal. Authors must wait for an editorial decision or formally withdraw the submission before submitting the manuscript elsewhere.

Further information regarding corrections and article retractions is available on the Retraction and Correction Policy.

6. Screening Procedures and Handling of Alleged Misconduct

When indications of plagiarism or duplication are identified, the editorial team handles the case proportionately and on the basis of evidence. The procedures include:

  1. Initial screening: The editor reviews the similarity report and identifies sources and manuscript sections requiring attention.
  2. Contextual evaluation: The editor assesses the nature of textual overlap, citation accuracy, similarity levels, and the possibility of legitimate use.
  3. Author clarification: When necessary, the corresponding author is requested to provide an explanation or supporting evidence within a specified timeframe.
  4. Editorial decision: Based on the evaluation, the editorial team may request revisions, return the manuscript, reject the submission, or proceed with peer review if no misconduct is identified.
  5. Escalation: Serious allegations that remain unresolved may be referred to the author's institution or other relevant authorities.
  6. Documentation: Evidence and communications related to the case are documented as necessary for the editorial process and confidentiality requirements.

Screening and investigation are conducted according to the principles of fairness, confidentiality, objectivity, and the author's right to provide an explanation. The handling of suspected misconduct follows relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

7. Actions in Cases of Confirmed Misconduct

When a violation of publication ethics is confirmed, editorial actions may include:

  • Requesting authors to correct citations, paraphrasing, or problematic manuscript sections when the violation is limited and can be appropriately corrected.
  • Rejecting a manuscript when substantial plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other serious misconduct is identified.
  • Retracting a published article when serious misconduct warrants retraction under the editorial procedures.
  • Publishing a correction or expression of concern when such action is more appropriate to the nature and severity of the issue.
  • Notifying the author's institution or relevant parties when necessary to address serious misconduct.
  • Considering restrictions on future manuscript submissions according to the severity of the violation, available evidence, and applicable journal policies.

Actions are determined according to the severity of the misconduct, available evidence, the author's explanation, and the implications of the violation for the integrity of the scholarly record.

8. Responsibilities of Authors

Every author is responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts represent original scholarly work and that all sources are properly acknowledged. Authors are required to:

  • Cite original sources for ideas, data, quotations, and materials originating from other authors.
  • Use quotation marks or appropriate direct quotation formats when reproducing text verbatim.
  • Paraphrase accurately without removing attribution to the original sources.
  • Transparently disclose the use of relevant materials from their own previously published work.
  • Ensure that the manuscript is not under consideration by another journal and does not constitute duplicate publication.
  • Obtain permission for the use of copyrighted materials when required.
  • Provide clarification and cooperate with the editorial team when questions arise regarding manuscript originality.

Authors are encouraged to use reference management applications such as Mendeley or Zotero and check citation consistency in accordance with the APA Style, 7th edition.

9. Manuscript Originality Declaration

Authors must ensure that submitted manuscripts comply with JIED's originality requirements and publication ethics. The editorial team may request an originality declaration as a supporting document during the submission process.

Author Declaration

We declare that the submitted manuscript is original scholarly work, is not currently under consideration by another journal, and does not contain plagiarism or inappropriate duplicate publication. All sources used have been appropriately acknowledged through accurate citations and references. We agree to provide clarification if the editorial team requires further examination of the manuscript's originality.

Authors may consult the APA Style guidelines to ensure that citations and references are presented consistently and accurately.

10. Post-Publication Screening

If allegations of plagiarism or duplication arise after publication, the editorial team will examine the available evidence, contact the authors when necessary, and determine appropriate action according to the nature and severity of the issue. Post-publication actions may include corrections, expressions of concern, or article retractions. Information concerning changes to an article's status will be communicated transparently in accordance with journal procedures and the principles of publication integrity.

Editorial Office — Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED)

Department of Pancasila and Citizenship Education
Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, Universitas Palangka Raya
Central Kalimantan, Indonesia
Email: Editorial Contact