Generative AI Policies

Generative AI Policies

Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) establishes this policy governing the use of generative artificial intelligence (Generative Artificial Intelligence or Generative AI) to safeguard academic integrity, transparency, accountability, and the quality of scholarly publication. This policy applies to authors, editors, and reviewers throughout manuscript preparation, peer review, editorial processing, and scholarly publication.

This policy is developed with reference to the Decree of the Director General of Science and Technology No. 374/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026 concerning the Technical Guidelines for Scientific Journal Accreditation, particularly Section C.3 on Artificial Intelligence Usage Policies, as well as established principles of scholarly publication ethics.

KEY REQUIREMENTS FOR AI USE

1. Authors must disclose AI use in manuscript preparation honestly and transparently.

2. AI cannot be listed as an author and must not replace human intellectual contribution or authorial responsibility.

3. Reviewers are prohibited from using AI in the peer-review process in accordance with the applicable scientific journal accreditation guidelines.

4. AI use by authors or editors does not eliminate responsibility for accuracy, integrity, confidentiality, and scholarly decisions.

1. General Principles of AI Policy

JIED recognizes that AI technologies may serve as supportive tools in academic activities. However, their use must be responsible and must not mislead readers, compromise the originality of scholarly work, or replace human scholarly judgment.

All AI use must observe the following principles:

  • Transparency: AI use that contributes to manuscript content must be clearly disclosed.
  • Accountability: Authors and editors remain responsible for their work and decisions.
  • Academic integrity: AI must not be used to fabricate, manipulate, or misrepresent scholarly information.
  • Confidentiality: AI use must not compromise manuscript confidentiality, research data, or personal information.
  • Human oversight: AI-generated outputs must be critically examined before being incorporated into scholarly work or editorial processes.

2. AI Usage Policy for Authors

Authors may use AI as a supportive tool within reasonable limits. However, AI use must not replace authors' intellectual contributions in formulating research problems, developing arguments, analyzing evidence, interpreting findings, and constructing research conclusions.

2.1. Permitted Uses of AI

Subject to disclosure and verification requirements, AI may be used for:

  • Assisting with spelling, grammar, and readability improvement;
  • Supporting language translation, provided that the accuracy and intended meaning are subsequently verified;
  • Assisting with the organization of ideas or the development of preliminary writing outlines;
  • Supporting technical tasks, such as coding or visualization, when relevant to the research and when outputs are appropriately verified;
  • Supporting other academic tasks, provided that such use does not replace authors' scholarly judgment or violate research ethics.

2.2. Restricted or Prohibited Uses of AI

Authors must not use AI to:

  • Replace authors' intellectual contributions in producing scholarly work;
  • Create research data, findings, interview quotations, documents, or evidence that were not genuinely obtained through the research process;
  • Manipulate data, images, tables, or analytical results to produce misleading representations;
  • Generate fictitious references, DOIs, quotations, or bibliographic information;
  • Commit plagiarism or conceal the use of others' intellectual work without appropriate attribution;
  • Present unverified AI-generated outputs as established facts or valid scholarly evidence;
  • Violate copyright, privacy, research ethics approval, or research data confidentiality requirements.

3. Disclosure Requirements for AI Use

Authors must disclose AI use that contributes to the preparation or development of substantive manuscript content. Disclosure must be honest, specific, and understandable to editors and readers.

The disclosure should include at least:

  • The name of the AI tool or service used;
  • The purpose of AI use;
  • The manuscript sections or research stages supported by AI;
  • The verification, evaluation, or editing performed by the authors on AI-generated outputs.

The AI usage statement should be included in the Methods, Acknowledgments, or a dedicated AI-use statement section, depending on the nature of the AI application. When AI is used in data processing or analysis, authors must adequately explain its role in the Methods section so that the research process can be critically assessed.

Example of an AI Usage Statement

"The authors used [name of AI tool] to assist with [specify the purpose of AI use] during the preparation of this manuscript. AI-generated outputs were reviewed and evaluated by the authors. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy of information, interpretations, arguments, and final content of the article."

This statement must be adapted to reflect the actual use of AI and must not claim verification procedures that were not performed.

4. AI Cannot Be an Author

Generative AI, chatbots, and large language models cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of articles published in JIED. Authorship is reserved for human contributors who meet the requirements of scholarly contribution and are willing to take responsibility for their work.

AI must not replace authors' intellectual contributions in research design, analysis, interpretation of findings, argument development, or conclusion formulation. Human authors remain responsible for every part of the manuscript, including materials generated or assisted by AI.

5. AI Policy for Reviewers

PROHIBITION OF AI USE IN PEER REVIEW

Reviewers of JIED are prohibited from using generative AI to conduct or replace manuscript peer review. This prohibition includes uploading unpublished manuscripts to AI services to generate evaluations, comments, recommendations, or peer-review decisions.

Reviewers must conduct assessments independently based on their scholarly expertise, available evidence, and principles of objectivity. Reviewers are responsible for all comments and recommendations submitted to editors and must preserve manuscript confidentiality throughout the peer-review process.

6. AI Policy for Editors and Editorial Team

Editors and the editorial team are responsible for maintaining the quality, integrity, confidentiality, and fairness of the publication process. If AI is used to support permitted editorial activities, such use does not eliminate editorial responsibility for the resulting work or decisions.

  • Editorial decisions regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection must remain under the authority and accountability of human editors.
  • Editors must verify the accuracy and relevance of AI-generated outputs before using them to support editorial work.
  • Editors must not submit manuscripts, reviewer reports, or confidential information to AI services that do not ensure adequate confidentiality protection.
  • AI use must not produce discriminatory, misleading, or professionally unsupported editorial decisions.
  • Editors must comply with journal requirements concerning transparency, data security, and publication integrity.

7. Verification of Information and References

Authors are responsible for ensuring that all information used in their manuscripts is accurate, relevant, and verifiable. AI-generated outputs cannot be treated as valid scholarly evidence without verification against the underlying sources or data.

  • Every reference must be checked for authenticity and metadata accuracy against the original source or a reliable database.
  • Every citation must genuinely support the statement for which it is cited.
  • Data, tables, figures, and analytical results must correspond to the actual research evidence.
  • Authors must correct errors identified in AI-generated outputs before manuscript submission or publication.

8. Confidentiality and Data Protection

AI use must respect manuscript confidentiality, personal data protection, copyright, research ethics approval, and the rights of research participants. Authors and editors must not submit sensitive data, informant identities, confidential interview transcripts, or protected documents to AI services without appropriate authorization and safeguards.

This requirement also applies to unpublished manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and other documents obtained through the publication process. All parties must maintain the confidentiality of information in accordance with their respective authority and responsibilities.

9. Investigation and Handling of Alleged Violations

Editors may request clarification regarding AI use, disclosure statements, data sources, references, or manuscript preparation when there are reasonable grounds for further examination.

Alleged violations will be addressed based on verifiable evidence, the context of the case, and the journal's publication ethics procedures. Actions may include:

  • Requesting clarification or correction of the AI disclosure statement;
  • Requesting verification of sources, data, images, or research findings;
  • Requesting substantial revisions when the manuscript can still be ethically corrected;
  • Rejecting a manuscript when serious violations are established or manuscript integrity cannot be verified;
  • Issuing corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions of published articles in accordance with applicable procedures and grounds;
  • Contacting relevant institutions when necessary to address serious allegations of misconduct.

Results from AI detection tools must not be the sole basis for concluding that a violation has occurred. Assessments must consider available evidence, explanations from relevant parties, and fair editorial procedures.

10. Authors' Declaration of Compliance

By submitting a manuscript to JIED, authors declare that AI use has been disclosed in accordance with this policy whenever disclosure is required. Authors also declare that all data, sources, citations, analyses, and manuscript content have been examined and can be appropriately substantiated.

Authors remain responsible for the originality of their work, accuracy of references, validity of data, compliance with research ethics, and all scholarly consequences arising from the content of their articles. AI use cannot be invoked as a justification for avoiding responsibility for errors or misconduct.

11. Policy Review and Updates

JIED may review and update this policy in response to developments in AI technologies, scientific journal accreditation requirements, and publication ethics guidelines. Any revisions will be communicated through the official journal website.

Editorial Office of Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED)

Department of Pancasila and Citizenship Education, Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, Universitas Palangka Raya, Central Kalimantan, Indonesia.

Website: https://e-journal.upr.ac.id/index.php/jied