Publication Ethics

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Logo

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)

The Journal of Islamic Education and Intellectual Discourse (JIED) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, academic integrity, transparency, and accountability. This policy is developed with reference to the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher throughout the publication process.

JIED expects all parties involved in scholarly publishing to uphold ethical standards, respect academic integrity, and contribute to the responsible dissemination of knowledge. The journal's editorial policies and publication procedures are available through the following pages: Publication Ethics, Peer Review Process, and Reviewer Guidelines.

Commitment to Academic Integrity
JIED does not tolerate plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, manipulation of the peer-review process, or other forms of research and publication misconduct.
1. Ethical Standards

JIED adheres to the ethical principles established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). The journal promotes integrity, fairness, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability in scholarly publishing.

All participants in the publication process are expected to observe the following principles:

  1. Maintain honesty and integrity in research and scholarly communication.
  2. Ensure that manuscripts contain original, accurate, and verifiable scholarly work.
  3. Respect confidentiality and intellectual property rights.
  4. Declare any conflicts of interest that may influence research or editorial decisions.
  5. Respond appropriately to allegations of research or publication misconduct.
  6. Promote responsible authorship, citation, peer review, and editorial decision-making.
2. Publication Decisions

The editorial decision to accept, reject, or request revisions to a manuscript is based on its scholarly quality, originality, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, methodological rigor, clarity of argument, and contribution to the field.  Editors must ensure that decisions are made fairly, objectively, and without discrimination based on the authors' identity, institutional affiliation, nationality, gender, religious background, or other personal characteristics.

Editorial decisions are informed by the journal's Peer Review Process and the scholarly assessments provided by reviewers.

3. Confidentiality

Editors, editorial staff, and reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and related correspondence. Manuscripts under review must not be disclosed to unauthorized individuals or used for personal, professional, or academic advantage.

Information concerning submissions may only be shared with individuals directly involved in the editorial and peer-review process, including authorized members of the Editorial Team and designated reviewers listed on the journal's Peer Reviewers page.

4. Conflicts of Interest

All authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose any financial, institutional, professional, personal, or other relationships that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their judgment or conduct.

Individuals who have a conflict of interest in relation to a manuscript must disclose it and withdraw from the relevant editorial or review process when appropriate. Editors are responsible for ensuring that conflicts of interest do not compromise the integrity of editorial decisions.

5. Duties and Responsibilities of Editors
EDITORIAL RESPONSIBILITIES
Editors are responsible for maintaining the quality, fairness, confidentiality, and integrity of the journal's editorial and publication processes.

The editorial responsibilities include the following:

5.1. Fair and Objective Decisions

Editors evaluate manuscripts based on academic merit, originality, relevance, methodological quality, and contribution to scholarly knowledge. Editorial decisions must be independent, impartial, and free from inappropriate influence.

5.2. Manuscript Confidentiality

Editors must preserve the confidentiality of manuscripts, author identities, reviewer identities, and editorial correspondence in accordance with the journal's Peer Review Process.

5.3. Reviewer Selection

Editors select reviewers who possess appropriate expertise and are able to provide objective, constructive, and timely assessments. Reviewer selection may involve the journal's Peer Reviewers and other qualified scholars.

5.4. Ethical Oversight

Editors must identify and respond appropriately to suspected ethical violations, including plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, and citation manipulation. Allegations must be handled according to the journal's Allegation of Research Misconduct policy.

5.5. Corrections and Retractions

Editors are responsible for initiating appropriate corrective actions when errors or ethical violations are identified in published articles. Such actions may include corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions in accordance with the journal's Retraction and Correction policy.

6. Duties and Responsibilities of Reviewers
REVIEWER RESPONSIBILITIES
Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, constructive, confidential, and timely evaluations of submitted manuscripts.

The responsibilities of reviewers are outlined in the journal's Reviewer Guidelines and include the following:

6.1. Contribution to Editorial Decisions

Reviewers assist editors in making informed editorial decisions by providing scholarly assessments of manuscript quality, originality, relevance, and methodological rigor.

6.2. Objectivity and Constructive Feedback

Reviews must be conducted objectively and supported by clear scholarly arguments. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate. Reviewers should provide constructive recommendations that help authors improve their manuscripts.

6.3. Confidentiality

Reviewers must treat manuscripts as confidential documents and must not disclose, reproduce, or use unpublished information for personal or professional purposes.

6.4. Recognition of Relevant Sources

Reviewers should identify relevant published works that have not been cited by the authors. Any statement that a claim, argument, or finding has previously been reported must be supported by an appropriate reference.

6.5. Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest and decline assignments when personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationships may compromise their impartiality.

6.6. Timeliness

Reviewers should complete evaluations within the agreed timeframe. If they are unable to review a manuscript or anticipate a delay, they should inform the editor promptly.

7. Duties and Responsibilities of Authors
AUTHOR RESPONSIBILITIES
Authors must ensure that submitted manuscripts are original, accurate, ethically conducted, properly attributed, and free from plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, and inappropriate authorship practices.

Authors are required to comply with the journal's Author Guidelines, Screening for Plagiarism, and Generative AI Policies.

7.1. Originality and Plagiarism

Authors must ensure that their manuscripts constitute original scholarly work. All ideas, quotations, data, and materials derived from other sources must be properly acknowledged and cited. Plagiarism in any form is unacceptable.

7.2. Accuracy and Integrity of Data

Authors must present research findings accurately and honestly. Data fabrication, data falsification, manipulation of research results, and misleading presentation of evidence are prohibited.

7.3. Multiple, Duplicate, or Concurrent Submission

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal. Manuscripts that have already been published substantially in another publication must not be submitted as original work without appropriate disclosure and justification.

7.4. Authorship and Contribution

Authorship must reflect substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript. All listed authors must have participated meaningfully in the work, approved the final manuscript, and accepted responsibility for its content. Individuals who do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately.

Authors are required to submit the Author Contribution Statement Form where applicable.

7.5. Citation and Reference Integrity

Authors must cite relevant and reliable sources that directly support their arguments and findings. References must be accurate, appropriate, and consistent with the journal's Citations and References Usage policy. Citation manipulation, irrelevant citation practices, and coercive citation are unacceptable.

7.6. Research Ethics and Disclosure

Authors must comply with applicable ethical requirements in conducting research, including obtaining appropriate ethical approval, informed consent, and permissions when necessary. Authors must disclose relevant funding sources, conflicts of interest, and other information that may affect the interpretation of their research.

7.7. Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Authors must disclose the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools when such use is relevant to the preparation of the manuscript and required by the journal's Generative AI Policies. AI tools cannot be listed as authors and do not replace authors' responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and scholarly content of submitted work.

7.8. Revision and Editorial Communication

Authors are expected to respond constructively to editorial decisions and reviewer comments. Revised manuscripts should clearly address reviewers' recommendations and provide appropriate explanations for suggestions that are not adopted. Authors must communicate honestly and professionally with the editorial team throughout the publication process. Authors may contact the journal through Editor Contact for editorial correspondence.

7.9. Corrections and Post-Publication Responsibilities

Authors must promptly inform the editor if they identify significant errors or inaccuracies in published work. Authors are expected to cooperate with the journal in issuing corrections, clarifications, or retractions when necessary, following the journal's Retraction and Correction policy.

8. Allegations of Research Misconduct

JIED takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously. Misconduct may include plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and other violations of academic integrity.

Allegations will be assessed carefully, confidentially, and fairly. The journal may request explanations, supporting documentation, or clarification from the authors and other relevant parties. Appropriate action will be taken based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the alleged violation.

Detailed procedures are available in the journal's Allegation of Research Misconduct policy.

9. Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Updates

JIED recognizes its responsibility to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record. When significant errors, misleading findings, or ethical violations are identified after publication, the journal may issue corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions as appropriate.

Post-publication actions are undertaken transparently and in accordance with ethical standards. The journal's procedures are described in the Retraction and Correction policy.

10. Ethical Responsibilities of the Publisher

The publisher supports the editorial team in maintaining ethical standards, academic integrity, and transparency throughout the publication process. The publisher ensures that editorial decisions remain independent and that appropriate procedures are available to address ethical concerns and allegations of misconduct.

The publisher works collaboratively with editors, reviewers, and authors to safeguard the integrity of the scholarly record and to ensure that publication practices remain consistent with recognized ethical principles, including the recommendations of COPE.

11. Ethical Guidelines and Related Journal Policies

The following policies and journal information complement this Publication Ethics statement and provide further guidance for authors, reviewers, editors, and readers.

A. Editorial Governance and Contact
B. Editorial Policies
C. Submission and Author Information
D. Additional Journal Information
Final Statement
JIED is committed to promoting ethical scholarly communication and protecting the integrity of academic publishing. All authors, reviewers, editors, and publishing partners are expected to comply with this Publication Ethics statement and the related policies of the journal. Any suspected violation will be addressed carefully, fairly, and transparently in accordance with applicable ethical standards and the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).